30 Days of Instagram Ads – Live Blogging Case Study

Instagram ads are finally available to everyone.

But…Have you tried to set up a campaign?

Instagram provides little to no insight on how to get started.

More Info Instagram Ads

In addition, there’s no case study data out there to help you determine what’s working and what’s not.

That’s why I’m writing this post.

In this post, I’ll be live blogging the end to end Instagram advertising process:

  • Setting up your Instagram advertising account
  • Selecting and testing different ad formats
  • Real, unfiltered data on CTR, CPC, conversions and more
Note: I’ll be updating this post frequently over the next 30 days. Bookmark it or sign up for our email list to stay in touch with our progress. Jump to:

Baseline Goals and Outcomes

I’ll be using Instagram ads to promote our Instagram analytics and marketing tool  (Social Insights). Our primary goal for the ad spend is to increase sign ups.

  • Goal: 2,000 users by 10/31/15
  • KPI: CPL (cost per lead)
  • Target: $1.25 each

Day 1: Setting up the ad account

Connect your Facebook Fan Page with Instagram

Instagram ads run through your Facebook account. The first thing we need to do is sync your Facebook Page with your Instagram account.

  • Head to your Facebook page (not personal profile, but fan page)
  • Click on Settings in the upper right hand corner
  • On the left hand side, select Instagram Ads
  • Add your Instagram account

Facebook Page Instagram Ads Setup

Check if “self serve” setup is available on your account:

  • Open up Facebook Power Editor
  • Create a new Campaign that has the objective of either Clicks to Website, Mobile App installs, or Video Views. (These are currently the only objectives supported by Instagram ads)
  • Click on the left side of the page and then click Create Ad Set
  • Select the new ad set and on the right side of the page, click Edit

Setting up IG Ads

  • Scroll down to Placement and look for Instagram listed at the bottom

Create Ad

How to run Instagram ads if “self serve” setup is not available on your account:

If you don’t have self serve Instagram ads currently in your power editor the only way to access them is through “Managed Ads” by an Agency that his been given access.
There are a number of companies that you can do this through.

  • Ampush
  • Brand Networks
  • 4C
  • Kenshoo
  • Nanigans
  • Salesforce Marketing Cloud
  • SocialCode
  • Unified

If you want to avoid the pain I have gone through researching pricing, shoot me some info about your business here.

Day 2: Exploring the Instagram Ad Types

Instagram ads present a powerful opportunity because they’re a true native ad type. In other words, they fit in perfectly with the context of the platform – no sidebars, no interruptions.

It’s important to understand the different ad types available to align them with our goals.

Carousel Ads

Carousel Ads: Allows you to insert multiple images for users to scroll through. You can also link out to an external site which triggers on click.

Image ADS

Image Ads: This ad type only allows for 1 image in the frame. Like the carousel ads, you can link out to an external URL.

Video Ads

Video Ads: You can share videos (with sound) that last for up to 30 seconds. You also have the option to link to an external URL.

*note at the time of this writing Carousel Ads are not live through the Power Editor for Instagram but will be shortly.

Instagram also provided the following specs for creative requirements:

Image ads

Design

Image ratio: 1:1
Image size: 1080 x 1080 pixels
Image may not include more than 20% text
Caption: Text only, 125 characters recommended

Technical

Image ratio: 1.9:1 to 1:1
Minimum res: 600 x 315 pixels (1.9:1 landscape) / 600 x 600 pixels (square)
Caption: Text only, max 300 characters
Limited support for landscape format

Available CTAs

Contact Us
Download
Learn More
Shop Now
Sign Up
Watch More

Sourcehttps://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/clicks-to-website/instagram-links/

Video ads

Design

Aspect Ratio: 1:1
Video: H.264 video compression, high profile preferred, square pixels, fixed frame rate, progressive scan
Format: .mp4 container ideally with leading mov atom, no edit lists
Audio: Stereo AAC audio compression, 128kbps + preferred
Caption: Text only, 125 characters recommended

Technical

Caption length text: Text only, max 300 characters
Video aspect ratio: 1.9:1 to 1:1
Length: 30 seconds max (limited availability)
Image ratio: May not include more than 20% text.
Minimum res: 600 x 315 pixels (1.9:1 landscape) / 600 x 600 pixels (square)
File Size: Up to 30MB max
Frames: 30fps max

Available CTAs

Watch More
Book Now
Contact Us
Download
Learn More
Shop Now
Sign Up

Source: https://www.facebook.com/business/ads-guide/video-views/instagram-video-views/

Day 3: Creating the First Ad Set

Instagram ads follow the same structure as Facebook:

  • Campaign
  • Ad set
  • Ad

Ad sets are where you define your goal, audience and spend.

Instagram Ads Campaign Setup

 

For the first ad sets I’m setting the goal as “clicks to website”. Normally on a campaign like this I would choose “website conversions.” This is not an option for Instagram ads at the moment so clicks to website will have to do.

It’s important to test Ad sets and tweak them based off the results that you are achieving. Take a look at my two initial audiences then I will talk about why I decided to set them up this way.

Social Media/Business

Location
United States
Age
18-40
Gender
All
Interests
Business and industry: Small business
Business and industry > Online: Digital marketing, Social media marketing
Additional Entries: ads manager, business, digital advertising, Federation of Small Business, small business owners, social media, social media marketing, Social media solutions, social media today, United States Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship, us small business administration

Business

Location
United States
Age
18-40
Gender
All
Interests
Additional Entries: American Business Women’s Association, american businessperson, big business, business networking, business plan, competative advantage, data analysis, Federation of Small Businesses, home business, independent business, retargeting, small and medium enterprises, small business administration, small business software

My target customer is someone who uses or intends to use Instagram for marketing purposes. I built these audiences to focus more on a B2B sale than a B2C sale. You can see from the interests I targeted exactly what I’m trying to do.

Here’s what an audience build looks like in the Power Editor.

ad set creation

I intend to build the exact same variation of ads in both of these ad sets. This will allow me to A/B test audiences, pick a winner and continue to test revisions.

Here’s what the ad structure looks like so far.

Adset

I may duplicate these ad sets to have the option to set separate daily budgets for video and image ads.

I’m working with a brand new website for this case study. Because of that I don’t have enough traffic yet to create any lookalike audiences. Later in this live blogging experiment I will create audiences based off of website traffic, email lists, etc.

This will allow me to compare how those audiences stack up compared to an audience built based on targeted interests.

Day 4: Image & Video Ads Creation

I’ve set up my Instagram ad account, linked the necessary Instagram accounts, explored ad possibilities and created my ad sets. Now I need to set up my initial ads.

The plan is to run both image and video ads to get data from all ads sets.

Currently in Power Editor you’re only able to set up single image ads and video ads. Carousel ads should be live soon and if they launch during this case study I’ll certainly run a few of them and add their results.

Here is how I set up my image ads:

campaign

I’m running 3 different image ads within each ad set I created – all 6 ads contain the same copy (the testing variables are the images). This will allow me to test which image performs best on Instagram then I can eliminate the other images and start testing different copywriting on the ads.

Peace

Follow

Yoga

Instagram is a visual network so you need to use pictures that will feel natural to a users feed.

Next, I set up video ads. The plan is to run 2 different versions of the video ad both using the same video but different copy writing. This will allow me to A/B test my copywriting and buy me some time to finish another video.

VideoAd1

VideoAd2

After setting up these ads I duplicated my two ad sets and put the video ads in their own ad sets to give me better control of my spend.

At this point everything is set up and pending ad approval from Facebook. Instagram ads do take a bit longer than regular Facebook ads to be approved, however they do state that it should not take over 24 hours.

Day 5: First Day of Ad Spend

The ads were approved and the results are in!

1AdSetResults

Conversions: 20

The two main takeaways from these Ad Set stats:

  • Image Ads CPC is much lower than Videos Ads CPC
  • The Social Media/Business Audience performs much better

Lets take a look at the data from each Ad Set.

Ad Set (Business)

1BusinessAds

Ad Set (Social Media/Business)

1SocialMediaAds

Video Ad Set (Business)

1VideoBusinessAds

Video Ad Set (Social Media/Business)

1VideoSocialMediaAds

Takeaways:

  • The “Peace” & “Follow” images perform the best. (both had 8+ relevance scores)
  • Clicks on video ads were so low its hard to say what copy performed best.
  • Final CPL $3.99 (target is $1.25)
  • Landing page converting at 12%

I’m above my desired CPL but with a few changes it should be possible to hit it without issue. I think it’s possible to get my CPC on image ads into the $0.10 to $0.15 range. If I maintain the current 12% conversion on my landing page a $0.15 CPC will put me at a $1.25 CPL. If I can’t get my CPC that low I will have to bump the conversion percentage of my landing page. There are a few changes I feel I could make to get that higher.

Action Steps:

  • Remove video ads
  • Use Social Media/Business Audience
  • A/B test copywriting

These first ads gave a lot of insight. With a little more tweaking I don’t think the $1.25 CPL is out of sight. Keep in mind this is without any lookalike or retargetting audiences yet as well.

Day 6: Image ads & copywriting tests

After narrowing down the best audience and media type, it was time to double down.

I duplicated the Social Media/Business Audience, created 4 ads using the “Peace” & “Follow” Images and two different versions of copywriting.

Here are the results:

ImageSocialMediaAds

Conversions: 10

The main takeaways from this Ad Sets stats:

  • Average CPC dropped to $0.24
  • Landing page converted at only 6% (according to the reported website clicks. My Analytics show a little different numbers)

Lets take a look at the data from each Ad Set.

ImageSocialMediaAd

Takeaways:

  • The “Follow” images perform the best. (both had 9+ relevance scores)
  • Lowest CPC yet of $0.17
  • Despite the lower CPC the CPL remained at $3.99 (target is $1.25)
  • Landing page needs to be reworked to boost conversion

Day 7 & 8: Landing page optimization

Creating a funnel for Instagram ads is a little different than your typical Facebook ads funnel. You’re advertising inside an app. This means that almost 100% of your traffic will be mobile or tablet based.

I need to desperately up the conversion rate on my landing page. There are some major pain points on mobile that don’t exist on desktops.

Mobile pain points:

  • popup optins
  • excessive data entry
  • non responsive page designs

I had some of these pain points in my existing landing page. It was a 2 step optin with a popup and required a first name and an email address. The page also showed a full breakdown of the tool features and gave a lot of information.

I decided to completely strip down the landing page and make it about as basic as possible. 60% of users were not viewing anything bellow the fold. No need to add that information at this time, while instead I can direct them to that information on the Thank You page.

Here is a screenshot of the updated basic landing page.

IMG_6189

Day 9: Creating a lookalike audience

Facebook provides some really good ways to create targeted audiences. The more targeted your audience, the more efficient your ads should be. In order to take advantage of any of these features though, you must have a Custom Audience Pixel installed on your website.

How to create a custom audience pixel:

In Power Editor or your Ads Manager

  1. Click Tools from the top menu
  2. Click Pixels > Custom Audience Pixel
  3. Click Create a Pixel
  4. Give your pixel a name. There’s only one pixel per ad account, so choose a name that represents your business.
  5. Click Create Pixel
  6. Copy and paste the generated Pixel code to the <head> section of everyone of your website pages.

Pixel Code

I had installed this pixel on the Social Insight website as soon as it was created, at the end of September. This allowed me to create a Custom Audience in my Ad account of individuals who have visited the site and have a Facebook account.

This Audience is small (1,300) but I know for the most part they are all individuals in my target demographic. A lookalike Audience will be a much larger Audience, Facebook generates an audience that aligns with the characteristics of my current traffic.

How to create a lookalike audience:

  1. Go to Ads Manager
  2. Select Tools > Audiences
  3. Click Create Audience and select Lookalike Audience
  4. Choose an existing customer group for your Lookalike Audience

lookalike audience

Next, choose the size of your audience. A smaller audience will have more similarities with your source customer group. A larger audience will be less precise, but will offer you more reach.

lookalike audience select

Here are my finished lookalike audiences

Custome Audiences

Day 10: $1.13 CPL ad spend

WE DID IT! I got my cost per lead down to $1.13 per lead. That’s below my goal of $1.25 CPL!!

Here is the campaign.

1dollarads

Conversions: 40

Here is a look at how the two Ad sets did individually.

(Lookalike) leadpages Ad Set:

1dollaradsCPC

CPM

1dollaradsCPM

(Lookalike) clickfunnel Ad Set:

1dollaradsLow

CPM

1dollaradsLowCPM

As you can see the Reach and CPM are a lot different in these two ad sets. I am running the exact same ads in these Ad Sets the only difference is the bidding option I chose. For the (Lookalike) leadpages Ad Set I chose “Link Clicks to Website/Pay per Impressions” and for the (Lookalike) clickfunnel Ad Set I chose “Impressions.” Since the (Lookalike) leadpages Ad Set was performing a little better I ended up turning off the other and continuing with just that one.

Updated ad copy

Peace2

Follow2

Now I will scale this Campaign to see if we can maintain this CPL at scale!

Day 11 & 12: CPL at scaled ad spend

I scaled the ad spend and the results are in! I decided to bump the (Lookalike) leadpages Ad Set up to $20 a day and run it for a couple days like this. It was getting me the highest CPC so I figured it would do best at scale.

Here is what things look like!

scaledspend

Conversions: 108

The new CPL at scale is $0.91! We are generating leads for under a $1 each! Well below the goal of $1.25 each.

Besides just the CPL dropping some of the ads CPC came down as well.

scaledspend1

Towards the end of the second day I completely stopped running the “Follow” ad. The CPC was much higher and the other ad was performing much better.

There are a few reasons I think my CPL came down once I started to scale.

  1. Social Proof: As the reach on my ads extended, the likes rolled in and people started tagging there friends in the comments. This gave me an increased organic reach and social validated the ad to the following people who saw it. Check out the response to the “Peace” ad in this Ad Set https://instagram.com/p/8rtBIXSUO9/
  2. Better Algorithm Data: For this ad set my targeting goal was “Link Clicks to Website/Pay per Impressions.” This means Facebook is going to try and show my ad to those most likely to click it because they know this is my goal. As more people click the ad Facebook can better learn what people are interacting and serve your ad to a more dialed in prospect.
  3. Increased Conversion: The landing page conversion rate went up.

Day 13 & 14: Tripwire offer is live

Now that the CPL was all dialed in on my ads I knew I needed to put together my full tripwire funnel and autoresponder campaign.

First I created my tripwire product, the “Instagram Growth System.” Its a short execution plan of step by step techniques to grow your Instagram following by 10,000 followers in 30 days.

Course

This is a full course but contains a lot more than a typical blog post. The goal was to create a piece of content that provided HUGE value at a $7 price tag.

Next I changed my “thank you” page after optin to a thank you / upsell page. You can see an example HERE

Then I qued up a 3 day autoresponder to go out to those who did not purchase!

After 24 hours, and about $30 in ad spend, we have 4 sales!

dashboard

This almost completely offsets my ad spend. After the Autoresponder emails start hitting people over the next few days I am confident it will exceed the ad spend. This will make it easy for us to scale these ads to any monthly Ad spend we want.

I cant wait to update you all on how it goes over the next few days! Feel free to leave any questions about this in the comments. I only touched on the major points.

Day 20: Running stats

Recently I decided to upload my campaigns to Adespresso to try and get a little more statistical insight on my campaigns. That means the pictures for the ad stats will look a little different

Here is an update on the current numbers! All these stats are refreshed numbers starting at the lunch of the full funnel including the tripwire offer.

Adespresso Instagram ads stats

clickfunnelslanding

Stripe tripwire sales

Takeaways:

  • Current CPL is $1.03 (that’s well below the goal of $1.25!)
  • Tripwire conversion is at 14% (right where I need to be!)
  • Reported clicks and page analytics of visitors has a large gap. (Google analytics of visitors shows 518 for this page)
  • Landing page conversion compared to reported ad clicks is at 20%. (38% conversion based on google analytics stats)
  • 591 like and 29 comments on the Instagram Ad
  • Current beta list sign ups at 1,215

Action Steps:

  • Implement “Dayparting” an Adespresso feature that allows you to run your ads during the historically highest performing times.
  • Test another image to reduce redundancy
  • Test raising the tripwire price to $10 from $7

Day 21 – 31: Don’t rain on my parade

If you were following along in real time, you know the updates slowed down quite a bit. I was getting really excited because I saw that I could easily meet the goal of 2,000 beta sign ups by the 31st.

In order to hit that goal, and test scaling even more I cranked the budget up on my ads even more. I adjusted to spend $75 a day for the remainder of the month. I figured this would give me 80+ sign ups a day and allow me to hit our goal without problem.

After a day, my ads stopped be served. I mean 0 additional impressions.

I thought maybe I needed to tweak my audience, freshen things up a bit?

I spent 4 to 5 days tweaking and waiting to see if anything delivered impressions. No Luck.

I reached out to Facebook support at that point (which is notoriously slow). That began the waiting game for them to respond.

During that time I started to wonder if Facebook throttled my account for some reason. So I qued up the same ads with the same audiences on another Facebook Ads account I have.

Guess what.

The ads got impressions…

So I knew Facebook was throttling my ads account for some reason. However I still had not heard from support.

When I finally heard from them, they insisted that I was not being throttled and the girl I was talking to unfortunately did not know a lot about the platform. Pretty much a call center employee with a knowledge base she could access.

The day after my phone call with support, my ads miraculously started getting impressions and I have not had any problems since.

Unfortunately that was on the 31st so my time was up but we still learned a ton about Instagram ads in this case study and I am glad that we are back in business!

Final Metrics

  • Goal: 2,000 users by 10/31/15 & CPL of $1.25
  • Actual: 1,591 users & CPL of $0.91

Leave a Reply 33 comments